Market structure and basics of thin markets FX trading
The Foreign exchange market is an over-the-counter (OTC) marketplace in nature. What this actually means is that there is no one single central governing authority, and the market is mostly decentralized. Trading occurs through a network of liquidity providers, also known as LPs, which are usually large banks, brokers, and electronic communication networks or ECNs. While in normal market conditions this network can provide deep liquidity with a deep order book coupled with very tiny bid-ask spreads, the situation is totally different in thin markets. To trade low liquidity markets without knowing these details means exposing yourself to several risks simultaneously. In low liquidity Forex markets, this depth of order book no longer exists, and prices can swing up and down very quickly, which is very risky.
Market depth and trading sessions
Market depth is heavily influenced by trading sessions, especially when they overlap. The most liquid sessions are in London and New York, and when they overlap, the markets become most active, characterized by deep liquidity and fast price movements. Asian sessions, on the other hand, have historically lower liquidity as they have fewer trader participants. Institutional traders rely on tools such as consolidated limit order books known as CLOBs to see available liquidity across asset classes, but even those tend to show lower volumes during quiet markets.
Last look behavior
“Last look” behavior is a key factor during low liquidity periods. It is a practice where liquidity providers can reject or even requote a trade if the market rapidly moves against them during trade execution. This can increase rejection rates when markets experience thin liquidity periods. This can make it difficult to open a trading position during thin markets and cause losses due to missing good setups. ECNs and prime brokers might display an order book that looks stable, but if real resting orders are few, a single aggressive order can cause spikes where the price can sweep multiple levels, resulting in a sudden spike or drop.
Understanding and anticipating these structural characteristics of thin markets is critical for traders who participate in thin markets FX trading. Without being aware of these details, the price will seem erratic, and technical setups will mostly be unreliable.
When and why do low liquidity situations in Forex occur
Low liquidity situations in FX markets are most common during trading hours when trading sessions are ending. For example, when the New York session ends and Tokyo opens, the liquidity is usually very low and the order books are thin. This often translates into exaggerated price movements. Liquidity also tends to dry up during holidays such as Christmas, New Year, or major regional public holidays when banks and other institutions are closed.
Common causes of liquidity problems
Session gaps like the Sunday opens are another source of thin trading market conditions. Lack of orders over the weekend means any new flow can cause large price reactions. Macro events like central bank announcements or geopolitical events can create brief periods of low liquidity as market participants reassess their risks. This is especially true when the news event is scheduled to be released and can impact markets greatly. Broker-specific factors sometimes also play a role. Some brokers rely on a limited set of LPs, and if those LPs withdraw quotes temporarily, retail traders will get wider spreads than usual or no ability to open a trade at all. Technology issues, connectivity challenges, or even a surge of news-related traffic can contribute to sudden liquidity drops, which makes it risky to trade the markets.
Recognizing these patterns early allows traders to anticipate when liquidity may be lower than usual and adjust position sizing or strategies accordingly. Lowering position sizing while increasing stop loss distances is a common effective strategy against liquidity shortages in FX markets.
Challenges of Forex trading in low liquidity
Trading the forex markets during low liquidity hours introduces a set of unique challenges that can quickly catch an unprepared trader off guard. The first and most visible issue is usually widening, making it very difficult to trade profitably on lower time frames. While high liquidity sessions offer lower spread possibilities on major pairs, thin markets may widen to several pips, which greatly increases transaction costs and lowers profitability significantly. Imagine having a scalping strategy on a 5-minute timeframe only to see spreads reaching 2-3 pips, quickly hitting the stop loss, while the price continues in your direction. Even if you could close the trade profitably, trading costs would evaporate those profits quickly. This is especially true on major pairs where common movies include 2-4 pip price swings, making it near impossible to profit when spreads go beyond 1 pip. Surely, if you trade on an hourly timeframe or beyond, this is less of an issue, but for scalpers, lower spreads are life-changing.
Slippage and partial fills
Low liquidity FX trading is risky because of slippages as well. Slippage is a common problem as orders that appear executable at a certain price may fill several pips away, especially when market orders are used. Market orders are order types that are filled immediately at the best available price. Scalpers and high-frequency traders will lose money if even a small amount of slippage occurs, as it can completely wipe out expected profits. Partial fills are also a noticeable threat, especially for larger trading orders. In low liquidity conditions, the order book might not have enough orders resting at the quoted price, which usually leads to either a split fill at multiple prices or a completely rejected trade.
Gaps
Gap risks are also elevated during low liquidity in Forex. Because of fewer participants, the liquidity is lower, and a news headline or a sudden inflow or outflow of money can cause the price to gap up or down without trading through intermediate levels. Imagine having a stop-loss at 1.1010 on EUR/USD for the price to suddenly move past the level and go to 1.1009, which means larger losses. Traders holding positions through these periods of thin markets can experience serious profits or losses without the ability to manage the position in real time.
Technical indicators become less reliable when liquidity falls. For example, a moving average or oscillator can often generate false signals due to erratic price spikes, which cause a serious impact on indicator readings. Volume-based indicators also tend to become misleading because volume drops dramatically than usual and forces the indicators to become very unreliable.
Order rejection rates increase as liquidity providers are more cautious not to make mistakes. This usually leads to trader frustration in low liquidity hours, and they need to tighten risk controls, be much more patient than usual, and use a different set of rules specifically designed for low liquidity conditions.